Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Town Hall #2 - Chancellor Katehi meets w/ Faculty/Staff; Katehi receives much support

Quick post regarding the Town Hall meeting at UC Davis between the administration and faculty and staff.  I am going to tell it through pictures and twitter posts (mostly mine, with a few responses).  Will really try to write up a more essayish post ASAP.  I tried to match pictures to comments but some may be mismatched - please forgive me.  

If you want the punch line - it is pretty simple - lots and lots of support for Chancellor Katehi from faculty at staff with a few dissenting points of view.  Very few argued for the need for resignation (I think Nathan Brown was the only one but I may be wrong - Josh Clover and possibly others may have also said something along these lines).  And most said something positive about Katehi although most of the positive things were about how good a Chancellor people think she has been not about her handling of this incident and its aftermath.  Anyway - here are some pics and tweets ... Also note I tried to record a few videos here and there and for some reason the only two that came out well were of two of the biggest critics of Katehi - Clover and Brown.  I am including those vids though if you only look at the vids you will get a mistaken impression regarding the amount of criticism vs. support for Katehi. 

Once again - banners are not allowed.  WTF?
phylogenomics
The Tree of Life: Faculty and staff arriving for Town Hall meeting with Chamcellor http://t.co/1cjHtgML
11/29/11 4:09 PM

michaelhoffman
@phylogenomics Why is the sign partially covered?
11/29/11 4:34 PM


People getting lottery numbers to speak

Gratuitous extra picture






phylogenomics
Chancellor Katehi is now giving an opening mini statement to Town Hall #OccuppyUCDavis http://t.co/011ZM0IC
11/29/11 4:11 PM


phylogenomics
Katehi is saying that this has been a very very difficult 10 days #ucdavis
11/29/11 4:12 PM

phylogenomics
Katehi also says there has been a lot of misinformation out there #ucdavis #OccuppyUCDavis http://t.co/plbmT3jN
11/29/11 4:14 PM

oceangyre
@phylogenomics For Katehi to decry "misinformation" when she's been its biggest purveyor with regard to #OccupyUCDavis is rich. #OWS
11/29/11 6:31 PM

oceangyre
@phylogenomics Katehi has persisted in making insinuations about "outside elements" + health/safety @OccupyUCDavis that are all untrue. #OWS
11/29/11 6:33 PM

phylogenomics
Katehi says people responsible will be punished & that due process is needed & that there should not be a rush to judgement #OccuppyUCDavis
11/29/11 4:17 PM


phylogenomics
Katehi says she feels fully responsible for everything that happens on campus ( though I note - not sure what this means) #OccuppyUCDavis
11/29/11 4:18 PM

phylogenomics
Katehi says what happened at #UCDavis underscores much larger issues #OccuppyUCDavis
11/29/11 4:21 PM


phylogenomics
Front of hall here very empty-not sure if that is due to the silly "reserved" sign or some statement #OccuppyUCDavis http://t.co/EN0UYeK7
11/29/11 4:25 PM

xpeanutgalleryx
@phylogenomics so many empty seats.
11/29/11 5:12 PM


phylogenomics
Katehi: 5 ideas for response 1. More faculty interactions w/ admin 2. Conflict resolution council 3. Outreach to parents #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:27 PM

phylogenomics
Katehi continued 4. Alumni outreach 5. Police outreach - notes this is just a beginning #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:28 PM

thinktankhero
@phylogenomics it doesn't sound like any of those ideas address increased tuition, institutional violence, or taking responsibility?
11/29/11 5:30 PM


phylogenomics
Provost says he is regularly bowled over by the greatness of this university and none of these are changed by this incident #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:30 PM


phylogenomics
Provost Hexter says nobody is a stronger advocate for #ucdavis than Chancellor Katehi #occupyucdavis http://t.co/6DKXBeL8
11/29/11 4:31 PM

phylogenomics
Provost and Chancellor both say they are limited due to investigations in providing certain details publicly about events #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:33 PM

KMBTweets
@phylogenomics That. Is. Bull. Shit.
11/29/11 4:34 PM

phylogenomics
Student drawing numbers from a bin to determine who makes comments #occupyucdavis http://t.co/0U0Gnymd
11/29/11 4:35 PM



phylogenomics
Prof Nina Amenta in support of Katehi - says she does not want this to turn into a circular firing squad http://t.co/KTvLlbsI
11/29/11 4:37 PM



phylogenomics
Speaker says he is glad to see administration re-engaged - also says he wants to know where $$ is going http://t.co/h9mfcc5O
11/29/11 4:38 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says we should think about salaries and other expenses in terms of cost to students #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:39 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker also asks for more detail about the instructions Katehi gave to police - she says she cannot comment about it #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:40 PM

wilson_to
Sketchy... RT @phylogenomics Speaker asks for details about the instructions Katehi gave to police - says she can'tcomment #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:42 PM

the_eco_thought
@phylogenomics how convenient... Thanks for covering this
11/29/11 4:44 PM




phylogenomics
Nathan Brown has just spoken and critiqued Katehi but went over the time limit and was cutoff - crowd did not support him #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:48 PM



jrblough
@phylogenomics Was he actively booed or just not cheered?
11/29/11 4:49 PM

phylogenomics
Note - I do not agree with many things Nathan Brown said but I wish he had been allowed to finish #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:52 PM

phylogenomics
@jrblough booed and people tried to clap him off stage
11/29/11 4:53 PM

phylogenomics
@jrblough But pretty gently
11/29/11 4:55 PM

jrblough
@phylogenomics Interesting. Thanks.
11/29/11 4:54 PM
phylogenomics
Speaker calls Nathan Brown irresponsible for calling for disbanding of police #occupyucdavis http://t.co/R1UmKOoc
11/29/11 4:53 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says rather than focusing on blaming should focus on what to do for students #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:55 PM

phylogenomics
Brown interrupted speaker when he said Davis Faculty association called for end of police; Brown said THEY did not but HE did #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 4:57 PM

phylogenomics
Multiple speakers express support for Katehi #occupyucdavis http://t.co/ssbqDWwo
11/29/11 4:58 PM






phylogenomics
Speaker asks about how Katehi is going to be transparent in decisions & asks her to not be evasive #occupyucdavis http://t.co/Ek8Uh4gU
11/29/11 5:00 PM




phylogenomics
Katehi says she needs to spend more time with students To discuss issues and she needs to earn trust #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:01 PM


KatehivilleNews
She's certainly prone to understatement. RT: @phylogenomics Katehi says she needs to spend more time with students...earn trust.
11/29/11 5:17 PM

phylogenomics
Josh Clover cut in line and asked about police presence on campus and got into a mini debate about this issue #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:08 PM

phylogenomics
Clover suggested the police make students unsafe; Katehi says we need police and mentions V Tech; Clover says that is false fear mongering
11/29/11 5:09 PM


phylogenomics
Bob Ostertag : the first responses by Katehi was disaster & suggests UC admin angered students by that #occupyucdavis http://t.co/k59rQpNT
11/29/11 5:11 PM



phylogenomics
Ostertag says initial response by Katehi severely damaged university #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:13 PM

KatehivilleNews
This seems the crux of the issue. -> RT: @phylogenomics Ostertag says initial response by Katehi severely damaged university.
11/29/11 5:20 PM

phylogenomics
Ostertag also says not all students know medical bills will be paid #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:14 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker who has been here for 40 years & whose father was here says cannot use "danger" to justify what happens http://t.co/wNg4PDMl
11/29/11 5:16 PM


phylogenomics
Speaker says the university needs to support the message of the students - need to raise taxes on rich #occupyucdavis http://t.co/gHIos0xY
11/29/11 5:18 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says the privatization of the university is unacceptable and that he administration needs to fight this #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:20 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says camping on quad is nothing compared to "picnic day" here- should never have been an issue #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:21 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says real leadership will involve actual acting on behalf of students #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:22 PM

phylogenomics
Prof. Epstein class of UC Davis 1940 expresses support for Katehi and says real issue is funds #occupyucdavis http://t.co/d2SgIkNz
11/29/11 5:24 PM


phylogenomics
Next speaker says Katehi is not responsible for California budget issues and that what is needed is to change prop13 #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:26 PM


phylogenomics
Speaker: claim that "safety" & "health" excuse to remove students was more like middle East actions #occupyucdavis http://t.co/2a5xXLyt
11/29/11 5:28 PM



phylogenomics
Speaker asks if we can get a statistical sample of faculty to see what they feel #occupyucdavis http://t.co/KyJWdBgd
11/29/11 5:30 PM



phylogenomics
Speaker: he got 100+ faculty to sign letter of support for Katehi and that this is more than those calling for resignation #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:31 PM

the_eco_thought
@phylogenomics btw he is incorrect...
11/29/11 5:32 PM

phylogenomics
@the_eco_thought just trying to report quickly - will comment later
11/29/11 5:33 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker then asks how Katehi and police will deal with those who dissent and want her out #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:33 PM

phylogenomics
Katehi says "it will not be an easy discussion with the English department" #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:34 PM

shlocky
RT @phylogenomics "Katehi says "it will not be an easy discussion with the English department" #occupyucdavis" Best thing I've ever heard.
11/29/11 6:24 PM

phylogenomics
Police Captain says he is opening doors to try and listen as learn to make campus as safe as possible #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:35 PM



phylogenomics
Speaker from Engineering says he is impressed with undergraduate education at #UCDavis reads letter from student http://t.co/VIEIOHWd
11/29/11 5:37 PM



phylogenomics
Letter from student being read- student was impressed that Katehi has been cutting admin not student $$ #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:38 PM

thinktankhero
fyi, @phylogenomics is live-tweeting the town hall w/ Chancellor Katehi over #occupydavis. Interesting mix of opinions being voiced.
11/29/11 5:38 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker invites those making more than $80k on campus to take a pay cut #occupyucdavis http://t.co/MAQE0sR0
11/29/11 5:40 PM



phylogenomics
Speaker says she knows that taking pay cuts will not solve budget but will be a message to kids #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:41 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says not to forget inverse correlation between education funding and militarization of police #occupyucdavis http://t.co/cnaBFyGU
11/29/11 5:42 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker says university values are messed up with Capt Pike getting 100k while humanities profs get much less http://t.co/N2lu6bkR
11/29/11 5:43 PM

phylogenomics
Speaker asks if Katehi supports appointment of Bratton to head review - Katehi says she trusts Yudof to do right thing #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:44 PM




phylogenomics
Katehi says five investigations should reveal truth #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 5:45 PM

phylogenomics
And the town hall is over #occupyucdavis http://t.co/OkwvVXFg
11/29/11 5:46 PM







KatehivilleNews
From @phylogenomics summary of Chancellor's townhall, sounds like many faculty still back Katehi - English & Physics excepted #OccupyUCDavis
11/29/11 5:56 PM

phylogenomics
@KatehivilleNews yes - definitely lots of support for Katehi at meeting
11/29/11 5:59 PM

phylogenomics
Summary from Town Hall: Chancellor Katehi has strong though not unanimous staff and faculty support though #occupyucdavis
11/29/11 6:02 PM

j_real
@phylogenomics I'm glad to hear that. I hate kneejerk resignation demands.
11/29/11 6:04 PM

phylogenomics
@j_real I do too - though I think the administration has handled post-pepper spray issues very poorly
11/29/11 7:14 PM

j_real
@phylogenomics I think that's par for the course. academics aren't trained to handle crisis mgmt & PR; I presume most admin were profs first
11/29/11 7:16 PM

thomsparrow
@the_eco_thought I'm astounded by what @phylogenomics reports about Katehi support. Have I been duped by media hype?
11/29/11 6:33 PM

phylogenomics
Well @thomsparrow @the_eco_thought I've posted many links/letters on my blog from faculty/staff who support her http://t.co/UFYi9KpJ
11/29/11 7:06 PM

phylogenomics
@thomsparrow @the_eco_thought and I have seen the letter signed by 100s of faculty expressing support - it was sent to the Davis Enterprise
11/29/11 7:08 PM

phylogenomics
@thomsparrow @the_eco_thought I note - I did not sign the letter -it did not express enough disappointment
11/29/11 7:10 PM

2 comments:

  1. Thanks for recapping this. I am a staff person who might have liked to have gone, except for the part where most staff people have to work until 5 p.m. (I couldn't help but notice that when they sent out the e-mail for this, they did NOT say that staff could attend if they got supervisor approval, the way they do for convocation.) I can't help but wonder about the timing of this.

    I am surprised there was so much outright support. I don't particularly support her or am on her side at this point myself, but neither am I campaigning for her resignation either. (Frankly, I'm not sure if going chancellor-free for a year while they recruit another one will help anything, or that they'd get someone drastically different anyway.) I am staying neutral and will see how things go.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gosh I am such a doofus - I can't believe I did not notice the timing issue. As a faculty member, I just float around on my own schedule ... didn't think about people with, well, real jobs.

    ReplyDelete

Most recent post

Compiling some of my Twitter comments about the evolution and origins of SarsCoV2/ COVID19

 News Stories Quoted in UC Davis Aggie: Emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants raise concern for the future of the pandemic 9/15/2020. Newsweek.  Fact...