While watching my son, I had a conference call to "discuss" the education series for PLoS Biology. I put discuss in quotes since I have laryngitis and could not really speak. But Liza Gross signed on to gchat during the call and I sent her messages which she then read to the crowd. While on the phone I posted a few things to twitter too (must multitask):
- Protests again gathering steam on UC Davis campus | Davis Enterprise http://shar.es/ooVG7
- More honors for librarian at Birch Lane Elementary in #DavisCA #MyDaughtersSchool #GoLibrarians http://shar.es/ooVjb
- On conference call discussing PLoS Biology's: Open Education series tho hard to discuss w/ laryngitis http://shar.es/oWsSk
- ALEPDAVO @phylogenomics use your computer! macs can talk what you write remember? there's an option for that I think, although it might just spell
- @ALEPDAVO doing chat with other person on phone ...
- markowenmartin: @phylogenomics I tell students we are shedding microbes in an aerosol. Student made me this last year, in reply. pic.twitter.com/F132xlhA
- @markowenmartin that is awesome
- Cool example of PLoS Biology education papers: Bacterial Pigments as an Untapped Resource in the Classroom and Beyondhttp://shar.es/oWtHN
- Another PLoS Biology education pub: Metagenome Annotation Using a Distributed Grid of Undergraduate Studentshttp://shar.es/oWtxE
- Do you survey biological aerosols? If so – feedback wanted on protocols used http://shar.es/oW7XG #microBEnet
- The Tree of Life: Quick post: Do you survey biological aerosols? If so – feedback wanted on protocols used http://goo.gl/fb/PJ3G6
- Course Announcement: Introduction to Food- and Air-Borne Fungi, June 18-22 Ottawa http://shar.es/oWu4F
This is a "Tree of Life" collage by Michele Banks that I had purchased from her Etsy site. Spectacularly gorgeous by the way.
After this, we all headed off to my daughter's school for her class's "heritage festival." All the parent's were there and they had made various foods reflective of their kids heritage (my wife made alfajores - she is from Argentina). Here are some pics from the classroom:
To kick off the event, the kids sang a bunch of songs including "This land is your land"
And when everyone sat down to eat, I headed off to UC Davis campus where I work. But first I stopped at "The Paint Chip" in Davis to get my new Tree of Life art framed. I was not really sure what to do so I sent a twitter DM to Michele Banks the artist to ask for advice and she emailed me some suggestions. And I had sent her my phone number and she ended up calling to give some additional suggestions (we had communicated a lot on twitter but never by phone - with my voice the way it was, I am sure my first impression on the phone to her was a bit unusual).
And then I headed in to work. I got to my office that I have on "Main Campus" (where I go when I am teaching) and did a little bit of work (reviewing papers, sending email). And then at 2 PM I had another conference call, this one about the UC Davis search for a Librarian (we were getting a presentation by the Education Advisory Board about a study they had done on libraries). I called in on my cell phone, put in on mute (after introducing myself in a hoarse whisper) and started walking to the UC Davis Student Union area to get some tea. I had about an hour to "kill" before I needed to go to see Brad Shaffer lecture for our Intro Bio class at 3PM.
This was the first of two lectures for the class. The next was at 5. In this lecture I posted to twitter some of the things Shaffer was saying and had an interesting discussion with various folks that continued into the night:
- Brad Shaffer in intro bio at #ucdavis asks "what is the most meaningful measure of evolutionary success of a lineage?"
- LonettoMB Max L. @phylogenomics that is the kind of question I wish my intro bio professors had asked.
- Shaffer in intro bio says number of species is the best measure of evolutionary success of a lineage #ucdavis
- tjsharpton @phylogenomics I submit the following answer: its continued existence.
- well @tjsharpton that was one possible answer "age" ... But he likes # of species more
- joshwitten @phylogenomics Not being extinct, yet?
- @joshwitten I voted for "ecological success" mostly to be ornery
- @joshwitten your answer was kind of one of the possible choices: "age of lineage"
- joshwitten @phylogenomics I was going for something more or less definable, as the original question lends itself to semantic vagueness
- joshwitten @phylogenomics Similar. I was really thinking of binary rating. Most other measures tell us more about people advocating them than lineages
- @joshwitten binary rating?
- joshwitten @phylogenomics extinct=unsuccessful, not extinct=successful, no in between options
- artologica @joshwitten @phylogenomics What about Pandas? Terribly adapted, but still hanging in there.
- that's kind of why I went with "ecological success" as a measure@artologica @joshwitten
- joshwitten @artologica @phylogenomics "terribly adapted" is hard to judge & is dynamic as environment changes
- artologica @joshwitten @phylogenomics True, I guess the dodo was pretty well adapted to a predator-less existence
- vagheesh @phylogenomics answers from slightly inebriated bio grad students 1) that the species are alive today 2) homo is an unsuccessful species
- frabotta IMHO Brad has a myopic perspective - snapshot! MT “@phylogenomics: Shaffer... # of spp is best measure of evol success of lineage #ucdavis”
- sourpersimmon @phylogenomics 1) persistence 2) diversification. From a result-oriented view, any measure that scores algae at or near the top.
- dilefante @phylogenomics I'll go with having species adapted to a number of different environments/ecozones/younameit.
- CaliforniaAggie Students handcuffed. Tents being removed by police.
- CBSSacramento Students cheer as police leave. Watch more video from #UCDavis #Occupy arrests: j.mp/t2eR03 via @cbeckford13
But I really had no clue what had happened.
I posted a little "ditty" about how happy I was with the Tree of Life poster I had received:
- Oh frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!' I chortled in my joy - I have received my Tree of Life art from@artologica http://post.ly/3wghv
- And in the 2nd lecture of the day in intro bio at #ucdavis Brad Shaffer wins the teaching prize by bringing baby tur...http://post.ly/3wjM5
- Cephalopod Friday in Intro Bio at #ucdavis - hope @pzmyers is happy http://post.ly/3wjQn
- pzmyers No. I'm in the Midwest. RT @phylogenomics: Cephalopod Friday in Intro Bio at #ucdavis - hope @pzmyers is happy post.ly/3wjQn
- Thx @pzmyers you just made me laugh out loud while watching my colleague teach ....
- Woot - we have Riftia in class #chemosymbioses #microbesrule #tubeworms #deepsea #ucdavis http://pic.twitter.com/JhwgaE8A
And I kept an eye on twitter and started to see more detail about the police-student interaction. I RTd some of these but did not get to look at details.
- CaliforniaAggie The California Aggie Photos from today's Quad protest and police actions have been posted: goo.gl/ro1SM #occupy #UCDavis
- myhelicaltryst UC Davis police mace peaceful students protesting fee hikes#UCDavis #UCstrike #occupycal tinyurl.com/7gfpoy8@phylogenomics @MeghanDRosen
And then class ended and I rushed home. It was then that I was able to see some of the photos and video of the interaction between the police and the students. And to be honest, my day turned from one of nearly pure joy, into one of deep sadness, shock and dismay. Here are some of the pics and vids from the scene:
Ugggh. I don't really know what to say here. I usually sympathize with police in some of the interactions with protestors because the police are frequently put in a really hard spot trying to maintain control, enforce laws, and deal with dangerous situations. But this just seems from every way I look at it to be completely unacceptable. UC Davis, a campus that takes pride in the "Principles of Community" has turned into this? Students camping in the quad to express their opinions about a particular issue needed to be removed why? And they needed to be pepper sprayed why? I get that cities and campuses are freaked out about what to do with all these protestors camping in places. But there must have been an alternative to this. I am a bit tired now since I tossed and turned all night in regard to what happened yesterday. I am very worried about my campus now - what happened yesterday is not a path I expected UC Davis to go down. And I have no idea where it is going to go from here.
I feel similarly, although with a positive take on the outcome.ReplyDelete
It's difficult to characterize the dissonance of seeing this done on my old campus. My truly positive memories of the Quad, and attending grad school at Davis, are infused with the new, callously violent, image of this officer spraying seated nonviolent protesters - in their faces. Compounding the violence is the Chancellor's measured, passive-voice response to what happened as a result of her request.
Like you, I am generally sympathetic to the default police position in situations like this. The university requested a police presence and the officers presumably take their duties very seriously. Protests are designed to elicit an official response, to contradict administrations and to be difficult to ignore/disperse. But this? The brutality - and it was brutal - was unsolicited. And completely unnecessary. How can the Chancellor invoke a concern for public health while condoning, even praising, a police response response that included spraying pepper in the faces of seated students?
My positive take on the outcome is that the protesters appear to have successfully shamed the police into recognizing the humanity of everyone present - including the police themselves. In an era of increasingly militarized domestic police, that's a small but significant victory for protesters everywhere.
Interesting point - yes - clearly - in a weird way - the protestors won this round by a wide wide margin - maintaining dignity in the face of an excessive responseReplyDelete
At the same time, I can't help but wonder if the protestors aren't actually pleased at such a response. Most of these kids are the children of people who were the age of Vietnam-era protestors and probably grew up on tales of cops breaking up protests and fantasized taking part in a similar conflict. Protests aren't very exciting if the authorities ignore them. And probably riot cops fantasize about the other side.ReplyDelete
I can't imagine being pleased about being shot in the face with a stream of liquid carrying a pain-of-heat value (Scoville scale) an order of magnitude or more greater than that of the hottest pepper known and which can induce severe asthma: http://blogs.plos.org/speakeasyscience/2011/11/20/about-pepper-spray/ReplyDelete