Friday, October 07, 2011

The story behind Pseudomonas syringae comparative genomics / pathogenicity paper; guest post by David Baltrus (@surt_lab)


More fun from the community.  Today I am very happy to have another guest post in my "Story behind the paper" series.  This one comes to us from David Baltrus, an Assistant Professor at University of Arizona.  For more on David see his lab page here and his twitter feed here.  David has a very nice post here about a paper on the "Dynamic evolution of pathogenicity revealed by sequencing and comparative genomics of 19 Pseudomonas syringae isolates" which was published in PLoS Pathogens in July.  There is some fun/interesting stuff in the paper, including analysis of the "core" and "pan" genome of this species.  Anyway - David saw my request for posts and I am very happy that he responded.  Without further ado - here is his story (I note - I added a few links and Italics but otherwise he wrote the whole thing ...).

---------------------------------------
I first want to than Jonathan for giving me this opportunity. I am a big fan of “behind the science” stories, a habit I fed in grad school by reading every Perspectives (from the journal Genetics) article that I could get a hold of. Science can be rough, but I remember finding solace in stories about the false starts and triumphs of other researchers and how randomness and luck manage to figure into any discovery. If anything I hope to use this space to document this as it is fresh in my mind so that (inevitably) when the bad science days roll around I can have something to look back on. In the very least, I'm looking forward to mining this space in the future for quotes to prove just how little I truly understood about my research topics in 2011. It took a village to get this paper published, so apologies in advance to those that I fail to mention. Also want to mention this upfront, Marc Nishimura is my co-author and had a hand in every single aspect of this paper.

Tuesday, October 04, 2011

Something smells off with this - grant to fund travel to meeting, if you use Roche technologies

Just got this email from Roche announcing a grant program to pay registration and travel fees for the AGBT meeting if you are using Roche-454 sequencing or Roche-Nimblegen arrays as part of your work (see below).  Seems like this would have some of the same conflict of interest issues as a pharma company paying someone to give a talk.  I note - I participated in a session supported by 454 at a meeting but paid my own way to avoid this type of conflict of interest issue.  Anyone have opinions on this?  Is this a common pharma method creeping its way more and more into genomics?



Monday, October 03, 2011

Guest post from Katherine Scott of the Journal of Visualized Experiments on #OpenAccess challenges

Today we have another guest post here. This one is from Katherine Scott from JOVE - the Journal of Visualized Experiments. I really like the concept behind JOVE - high quality videos of experimental protocols. Publications in JOVE were initially freely available to all (see my 2008 post about JOVE here). Alas, a few years ago, things changed with the introduction of a subscription model. This saddened many out there, myself included, since JOVE was a wonderful addition to the collection of freely available scientific resources.  I wish they had been able to avoid this, but it seems that they could not.  Katherine Scott from JOVE explains their side of the story below:


Guest post by Katherine Scott "Open Access from the Perspective of an Academic Journal"

Open access from the perspective of an academic journal. I work for the first and only peer-reviewed science video journal indexed in PubMed and MEDLINE, the Journal of Visualized Experiments (JoVE). We started as an open access resource in 2006, but that model wasn’t sustainable for us. The cost of producing high-quality video simply too high.

So how do we remain profitable without losing our open access roots? Balance.

We started offering subscriptions in 2009, but still try to open up access wherever we can. We recently partnered with Health InterNetwork Access to Research Initiative (HINARI), to give free subscriptions to developing countries in South America, Asia and Africa.

Sunday, October 02, 2011

Wikileaks obtains internal Nobel Prize committee communications revealing 2011 winners

Stockholm. October 3, 2011. 

Well, Wikileaks has done it again. Though this time they have cracked one of the most secret organizations in the world - the Nobel Prize Committee, Julian Assange announced in a press conference today. Assange said
"We have obtained the entire database of email communications for all Nobel Prize decisions for the last ten years. To say the least, these provide a fascinating look at the secret decision making process."
The cables have not yet been released to the public. Assange said
"We are working with journalists to go through all the documents and redact out names in order to protect the innocent. There is some potentially damaging material in there and though we are inclined to release it immediately, we also understand there are risks. For example, there are many discussions disparaging the work of many famous scientists as being "obvious" or "inane." In addition, we have obtained all the nominations submitted from around the world, which includes a remarkable number of self-nominations by people who have done relatively trivial work."
Assange proceeded to show highly redacted examples of email communications from inside some of the committees, discussing things such as who would look good next to the King of Sweden or the King of Norway and thgat the peace prize award to Obama was given simply "for not being George Bush."

Assange also stated that the communications reveal the winners of the 2011 prizes which he was not going to reveal "in order to make a little bit of money on the side" to support Wikileaks activities. Although Assange did state that "I can conclusively state that Obama will not win the Medicine prize for his healthcare system" as some have suggested.

PLoS picture of the day: Simon Chan from #UCDavis sports #PLoSOne shirt when presenting to @BillGates

Good to see here that Simon Chan, from UC Davis, knows what is the best outfit to wear to present his work to Bill Gates.  
Thanks to Simon for sending me the photo and to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation for approving it'sits use here.

Burgess Sale vs. Shale

Every time I see this ad I clipped out twenty years ago, I think of Stephen Jay Gould and the Burgess Shale.  I sent it to him when I was a grad. student and would see this ad in the SF Chronicle for Burgess Honda.
Burgess_sale

Friday, September 30, 2011

Guest post from Antarctica: Joe Grzymski (@grzymski) on "The Story Behind Nitrogen Cost-Minimization"

Well, this is getting really fun. I have been doing "The Story Behind the Paper" posts for my own papers for a while and recently opened this up to guest posts. And the one today is coming to us from the true wilds - Antarctica. Joe Grzymski (aka @grzymski on Twitter) is out there doing field work (yes, microbiologists have the best field sites ...). For more on the field project see the Desert Research Institute's "Mission Antarctica" site. Joe responded to my request for more guest posts and wrote up a really nice discussion of a recent open access paper of his from the ISME Journal. If anyone else is interesting in writing a guest post on an open access paper or an issue in open access, let me know ... without any further ado -- below is Joe's post


I thoroughly enjoy reading Jonathan’s posts detailing – far beyond what can possibly be included in published papers – the who, what, where, when, why and how of science. The story behind the potential fourth domain of life article in PLOS ONE provides great detail about how science is done. After reading Matthew Hahn’s insightful history and commentary on his ortholog conjecture paper I was happy to reply to the request for more "stories" and am chiming in from Antarctica (where I am currently doing field research) to discuss the story behind our recent paper in ISME J, "The significance of nitrogen cost minimization in the proteomes of marine microorganisms". I hope it will provide another example of how a lot of science is lost in final, streamlined, published versions. Also, it is work that was largely done by an undergraduate and was vigorously and carefully reviewed – the improvements and expansion of ideas because of great reviewers highlights the best of the review process. What started out as a short two-page paper morphed into a larger piece of research – not things you can properly detail in a manuscript.

Most recent post

A ton to be thankful for -- here is one part of that - all the acknowledgement sections from my scholarly papers

So - it is another Thanksgiving Day and in addition to thinking about family, and football, and Alice's Restaurant, I also think a lot a...