I am very excited about today's post. It is the first in what I hope will be many - posts from authors of interesting papers describing the "Story behind the paper". I write extensive detailed posts about my papers and also have tried to interview others about their papers if they are relevant to this blog. But Matthew Hahn approached me recently about the possibility of him writing up some details on his recent paper on the functions of orthologs vs. paralogs. So I said "sure" and set up a guest account for him to write up his comments and details of the paper.
For those of you who do not know, Matt is on the faculty at U. Indiana. He was a post doc at UC Davis so I have a particular bias in favor of him. But his recent paper has generated some controversy (I posted some links about it here). So it is great to get some more detail from him. In addition, I note, I am also using this approach to try and teach people how easy it is to write a blog post by getting them guest accounts on Blogger and letting them write up something with links, pictures, etc. So hopefully we can get more scientists blogging too.
Anyway - without any further ado - here is Matt's post:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Following Jonathan’s excellent example of how explaining the history of a project helps to illuminate how the process of science actually happens, I thought I’d start by giving a bit of history behind our study, and the paper that we recently published in PLoS Computational Biology (http://www.ploscompbiol.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002073). And then I’ll address the critics…
Following Jonathan’s excellent example of how explaining the history of a project helps to illuminate how the process of science actually happens, I thought I’d start by giving a bit of history behind our study, and the paper that we recently published in PLoS Computational Biology (http://www.ploscompbiol.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002073). And then I’ll address the critics…
How this all got started
It all started a bit more than three years ago, in the summer of 2008. Pedja (as Predrag Radivojac is known to friends) was giving a talk to a group of us on protein function prediction that he also presented as a tutorial at the Automated Function Prediction SIG at ISMB 2008. Pedja and I had already collaborated on a small project involving the evolution of phosphoryation sites, but I really had no idea about his work on function prediction, and little idea in general about how function prediction was done. Reviewing different ways to accomplish transfer-by-similarity, he eventually got around to evolutionary (phylogenomic) approaches. Here is what I remember of this specific exchange during his talk: