Now there are lots of efforts out there to collect comments about papers. Faculty of 1000. The Third Reviewer. Research blogging. And much more. For other discussions of the issue see:
- Science in the Open » Blog Archive » The future of research ...
- Implementing the “Publication as Aggregation” - Cameron Neylon
- Aggregating, Tagging and Integrating Biodiversity Research
- How to Publish a Scientific Comment in 1 2 3 Easy Steps
- Soft peer review: Social software and distributed scientific evaluation
- and much much more
I am not really going to get into a discussion of all the ideas out there in this area. Some are good. Some are bad. Some are probably both. I personally think aggregation is going to be a very useful tool in post publication sharing and discussion and searching. But that is not per se what I am here to talk about. What I am here to talk about is what anyone can do right now to help with this in a very simple way.
My simple suggestion:
If you see ANY online discussion of a paper - a news story - a blog - even some smaller thread somewhere. Find the journal article online and use the comments function is the journal has one to post a comment saying "There was a news story discussing this paper in the New York Times. See ...." Or something like that. And presto, people who go see the paper online will also have potential to find the link you post.
I have been doing this for a while. It is relatively easy for PLoS Papers. For example for my paper on "Stalking the Fourth Domain in Metagenomic Data" I posted all sorts of links using the PLoS One comment function. I posted links to my blog. I posted links to positive news stories. I posted links to critiques. Anything I could find.
And this worked out pretty well.
My simple suggestion:
If you see ANY online discussion of a paper - a news story - a blog - even some smaller thread somewhere. Find the journal article online and use the comments function is the journal has one to post a comment saying "There was a news story discussing this paper in the New York Times. See ...." Or something like that. And presto, people who go see the paper online will also have potential to find the link you post.
I have been doing this for a while. It is relatively easy for PLoS Papers. For example for my paper on "Stalking the Fourth Domain in Metagenomic Data" I posted all sorts of links using the PLoS One comment function. I posted links to my blog. I posted links to positive news stories. I posted links to critiques. Anything I could find.
And this worked out pretty well.